Editor’s note: The following is the second of three parts of a special Devil’s Advocate series of commentary concerning the controversy over development in Williamstown.
By DAVE FEHR
The Willliamstown Select Board elections in May were focused heavily on issues of economic and residential development.
The town meeting did so as well, especially the articles concerning an elected vs. appointed planning board. If you went to the meet-the-candidates sessions, or followed the process in the papers, you heard and read some interesting viewpoints:
Philip Guy: “I do not agree with the contention that any residential growth is costing the town money. We need this extra revenue in order to continue fully funding our schools.” (He lost his Select Board seat.)
Ron Turbin: “Persuading software companies to relocate here might be easier than imagined.” (He won, and is now a selectman.) Ron, now that you’re in office, start persuading. You’ll find that it’s excruciatingly difficult, as the Berkshire Capital Investors and Village Ventures people know all too well. Those were local venture capital efforts with twin goals: (a) Generate a financial return to the investing partners, and (b) Create jobs in the region. The net result is, 10 years later, few remaining area jobs, maybe none in Williamstown itself. It was a shot worth taking, but the projects will likely not be replicated in Berkshire County. BCI and VV actually invested seed money in companies willing to locate here or, if they had begun here, to remain in the area and grow. Even that didn’t get the job done.
Dusty Bahlman: “Private developers should be asked to increase the town’s stock of lower-priced housing.” (He also lost.) You don’t (ITAL) ask (ITAL) developers, you offer incentives to them. If Cable Mills is a go, and provides some affordable units, it will be because town and state funding grants went to the developer to offset the losses he would incur when including these alongside his market-priced units. Same for the biscuit factory in North Adams. Around here, private money alone won’t support either affordable or low-income housing. Governments, churches, Williams College (Pine Cobble development, the old elementary school apartments) and charities must provide the extra funding needed.
Turbin, again: “I’ve always thought this would be a great place for a brewery.”
Continue reading "Everyone gets in on development talk" »